Skip to main content

Home › Blog › history

history10 min read

Do Jews Celebrate Thanksgiving? The 1789 Sermon That Answered It

Yes, most American Jews celebrate Thanksgiving as a civic holiday. The story starts in 1789, when Gershom Mendes Seixas preached at Shearith Israel on the first national Thanksgiving, and runs through Rabbi Moshe Feinstein's rulings, Thanksgivukkah, and the kosher table.

By The JewSA Crew•November 10, 2026
Key Takeaways
  • Most American Jews celebrate Thanksgiving as a civic holiday, closer to the Fourth of July than to a religious festival.
  • On November 26, 1789, the first national Thanksgiving, Gershom Mendes Seixas preached at Congregation Shearith Israel in New York.
  • Seixas urged Jews to support a government "founded upon the strictest principles of equal liberty and justice"; the sermon was printed in New York in 1789.
  • Rabbi Moshe Feinstein did not treat Thanksgiving as a religious holiday, and allowed a meal as long as it is not made an obligation.
  • Turkey is kosher by tradition; a kosher Thanksgiving keeps every side dish and dessert dairy-free.

Yes. Most American Jews celebrate Thanksgiving as a civic holiday, closer to the Fourth of July than to a religious festival. The Jewish connection runs deep: on November 26, 1789, the first national Thanksgiving under the Constitution, Gershom Mendes Seixas preached a thanksgiving sermon at Congregation Shearith Israel in New York.

That is not a modern rationalization. American Jews were at the table, so to speak, the very first time the country gave thanks together. My Jewish Learning puts today's reality plainly: "Most American Jews regard Thanksgiving as more akin to the Fourth of July than Christmas." Below is the full story: the 1789 service, what Seixas actually said, where his words survive, how leading rabbis ruled on the holiday, the once-in-a-lifetime Thanksgivukkah of 2013, and how to keep the whole meal kosher.

What Happened at Shearith Israel on November 26, 1789?

In the fall of 1789, the new federal government was months old. Congress asked the president to recommend a day of public thanksgiving, and George Washington issued his proclamation on October 3, 1789, signed "at the City of New York," according to the National Archives. He set the day for Thursday, November 26.

New York was the nation's capital, and it was also home to the oldest Jewish congregation in North America. Shearith Israel, the Spanish and Portuguese synagogue, answered the president's call. Its spiritual leader, Gershom Mendes Seixas, marked the day with a sermon, as the Center for Jewish History, home of the American Jewish Historical Society, recounts. A group of Jewish New Yorkers gathered in the synagogue that Thursday for what JTA calls "history's first Jewish Thanksgiving service."

The printed title of his sermon records the moment exactly. Robert Singerman's bibliography Judaica Americana lists it as "A Religious Discourse, delivered in the Synagogue in this City, on Thursday the 26th November, 1789," given in keeping with the president's proclamation for a national day of thanksgiving and prayer.

Who Was Gershom Mendes Seixas?

Seixas (1745 to 1816) was not a rabbi in the modern sense. Colonial congregations had no ordained rabbis, so he served as hazzan, the reader and minister who led services. The Jewish Virtual Library notes that Shearith Israel appointed him in 1768, at age 23, and that he served the congregation until his death, with one long interruption.

That interruption is the reason he is remembered as the patriot hazzan. When the British occupied New York during the Revolution, Seixas closed the synagogue rather than run it under British rule, the Center for Jewish History writes. He left the city with the congregation's Torah scrolls and later led Mikveh Israel in Philadelphia through the war years. After the peace, he came home and reopened Shearith Israel, and in 1784 he was appointed a trustee of Columbia College.

So when Washington called the country to give thanks in 1789, the man in the pulpit at Shearith Israel was someone who had already chosen the American side at real cost. For more of the history behind moments like this, see our guide to Jewish-American patriotic traditions, which includes Washington's famous 1790 letter to the Jews of Newport.

What Did Seixas Say in His Thanksgiving Sermon?

He built the discourse on the opening verses of Psalm 100, the psalm whose Hebrew heading is Mizmor l'todah, a psalm of thanksgiving. It begins with the call to "make a joyful noise unto the Lord, all ye lands." From there he made an argument that was bold for 1789: Jews owed gratitude to God, and gratitude meant taking part in American civic life.

The lines that still get quoted are about the new government. Seixas told his congregation it was their duty "to support that government which is founded upon the strictest principles of equal liberty and justice," as the Center for Jewish History quotes him. In the text as reprinted by the Jewish Historical Society of New York, he also thanks God that "we are made equal partakers of every benefit that results from this good government," and speaks of being "situated under the best of constitutions."

Read those phrases with the history in mind. In much of the world in 1789, Jews still lived as a tolerated minority under special restrictions. In the American capital, a Jewish minister stood up on a day proclaimed by the president and called his people equal partners in the republic. That is the oldest Jewish answer to whether Thanksgiving belongs to us.

Where Does the 1789 Sermon Survive?

In print, almost from the start. Singerman records the original as a 16-page pamphlet printed in New York in 1789 by Archibald M'Lean, with surviving copies held in library collections today. A notice in the New York Daily Gazette said it was published at the request of citizens who had heard it, not on Seixas's own authority.

In 1977, the Jewish Historical Society of New York republished it as A Religious Discourse: Thanksgiving Day Sermon, November 26, 1789, edited with an introduction by Isidore S. Meyer. The American Jewish Historical Society, at the Center for Jewish History in Manhattan, also holds several later synagogue Thanksgiving sermons in its collections.

Did Synagogues Keep Holding Thanksgiving Services?

For more than a century, yes. The Center for Jewish History describes synagogue Thanksgiving sermons as common through the nineteenth century and into the twentieth, and it highlights several in the AJHS collections:

  • 1845, Philadelphia: Isaac Leeser at Mikveh Israel praised American religious freedom.
  • 1863, Philadelphia: David Einhorn preached at Keneseth Israel on the first Thanksgiving proclaimed by Abraham Lincoln.
  • 1868, Philadelphia: Marcus Jastrow at Rodef Shalom objected when the governor of Pennsylvania framed Thanksgiving in Christian terms.
  • 1890, New York: Alexander Kohut, at the congregation that became Central Synagogue, praised American rights while raising alarm for the Jews of Russia.
By 1906, the Center notes, these services were reported as "meagerly attended," and attendance kept falling as Thanksgiving moved from the sanctuary to the dining room.

By 1906, the Center notes, these services were reported as "meagerly attended," and attendance kept falling as Thanksgiving moved from the sanctuary to the dining room. Shearith Israel is the exception. It has held Thanksgiving services since 1789, and JTA reports that the service "still runs today" at the congregation's historic building on Manhattan's Upper West Side.

Is Thanksgiving Allowed Under Jewish Law?

The halachic question is whether Thanksgiving counts as a non-Jewish religious holiday, which Jewish law tells Jews not to imitate, or as a secular national day. My Jewish Learning summarizes the mainstream answer: two of the leading Orthodox authorities of the twentieth century, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein and Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik, "both agreed that Thanksgiving was not a religious holiday."

Not everyone agreed. Rabbi Yitzchok Hutner considered the holiday off limits, and My Jewish Learning notes that "among haredi Orthodox Jews, Thanksgiving is not widely observed." Many Orthodox schools and institutions stay open that Thursday. For most of the American Jewish community, though, from Reform temples to Modern Orthodox families, the turkey is on the table.

What Did Rabbi Moshe Feinstein Rule About Thanksgiving?

Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, the most influential halachic decisor in postwar America, wrote about Thanksgiving several times in his collected responsa, Igrot Moshe, and his view was more nuanced than either side usually admits. Rabbi Moshe Kurtz walks through all of them in a 2025 essay for Tradition, the journal of the Rabbinical Council of America:

  • Even HaEzer 2:13 (1963): Mostly about scheduling Jewish events on non-Jewish holidays. On Thanksgiving, Rabbi Feinstein found "no formal halakhic prohibition," though he said the very scrupulous should be stringent.
  • Orach Chaim 5:20:6 and Yoreh Deah 4:11 (1981): More severe in tone. He wrote that establishing Thanksgiving as a holiday should be forbidden, while rejecting any idea that it is idolatry, and admitted the exact nature of the problem still "requires further analysis."
  • Yoreh Deah 4:12 (1981): His longest treatment. He concluded it is "preferable not to celebrate it," while allowing observance as long as it is not treated as a religious obligation.

In plain terms: Rabbi Feinstein did not treat Thanksgiving as a forbidden gentile festival, and his writings leave room for a family meal on that Thursday, provided nobody turns it into a quasi-religious holiday with obligations of its own. Rabbi Soloveitchik was more relaxed still. As OU Kosher notes, he permitted celebrating Thanksgiving, holding that it does not amount to adopting the customs of other nations.

If your family follows a specific rabbi or community, ask them. That is how halacha works in practice, and on Thanksgiving the range of good answers is wide.

What Was Thanksgivukkah?

In 2013, the Jewish calendar and the American one collided. The first Hanukkah candle was lit on the evening of Wednesday, November 27, according to Hebcal, which made Thanksgiving, Thursday, November 28, the first full day of Hanukkah. American Jews named it Thanksgivukkah.

JTA credits Dana Reichman Gitell, a marketer in the Boston area, with turning the coincidence into a communal event. A ten-year-old named Asher Weintraub designed the Menurkey, a turkey-shaped hanukkiah. Tables filled with sweet potato latkes and pumpkin challah. JTA called it "a calendar rarity that won't happen again for another 80,000 years."

A close cousin comes much sooner. In 2070, Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 27, and Hebcal lists the first Hanukkah candle for that same evening. Why the two holidays drift together and apart is a calendar story of its own, told in our guide to why Hanukkah is on a different date every year.

How Do You Make a Kosher Thanksgiving?

The centerpiece is easy: turkey is kosher. That is not obvious, since turkey is a New World bird and Jewish law accepts birds by tradition, called mesorah. OU Kosher explains that the turkey "gains its kosher status based on mesorah," and quotes Rabbi Chaim Loike, the OU's bird expert: "It's this holiday that reminds us turkey is kosher."

The real work is in the side dishes. Kosher law separates meat and dairy, and poultry counts as meat for this purpose. The Mishnah already ruled that birds may not be eaten together with cheese (Chullin 8:1). That changes the classic American menu:

  • Buy a kosher-certified turkey. Kosher poultry is slaughtered and then salted and soaked to draw out the blood, which My Jewish Learning notes vendors generally do before sale.
  • No butter or cream with the bird. Mashed potatoes, stuffing, rolls, and green bean casserole get made with olive oil, margarine, or a plant-based butter so they stay pareve, meaning neither meat nor dairy.
  • Make dessert pareve too. Pumpkin and pecan pies work well with a pareve crust and a nondairy topping.
  • Or plan for the wait. After meat, families wait anywhere from one hour to six before dairy, depending on custom, per My Jewish Learning's guide to waiting between meals. A coffee-and-cheesecake course can come much later in the evening.

If your family's relationship with kashrut is somewhere in the middle, you are in good company. Our tour of kosher, kosher-style, and kosher-ish covers the whole American spectrum.

Why Does Thanksgiving Feel So Jewish?

Partly because gratitude is the backbone of Jewish prayer, and partly because of a happy accident of language. In Hebrew, hodaya means thanksgiving, and My Jewish Learning points out that it is not far from hodu, the Hebrew word for turkey. Hodu is also the opening word of a line Jews have sung for millennia, "give thanks to the Lord, for He is good."

Mostly, though, it feels Jewish because Jews helped make it American. On the first national Thanksgiving, a hazzan who had refused to serve under the British stood in his synagogue and called the Constitution the best there was. Two centuries later, his congregation still gathers on that Thursday. So this November, when someone asks whether Jews celebrate Thanksgiving, you can tell them the truth: we were there from the first one.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do Jews celebrate Thanksgiving?

Yes. Most American Jews celebrate Thanksgiving as a civic, national holiday, much like the Fourth of July. Jewish participation goes back to the first national Thanksgiving on November 26, 1789, when Shearith Israel in New York held a service.

Who gave the first Jewish Thanksgiving sermon?

Gershom Mendes Seixas, hazzan of Congregation Shearith Israel in New York, delivered it on Thursday, November 26, 1789, the day George Washington proclaimed for national thanksgiving. It was printed in New York that same year.

What did Gershom Mendes Seixas say in his 1789 sermon?

Building on Psalm 100, Seixas urged Jews to give thanks and to support a government "founded upon the strictest principles of equal liberty and justice," calling the new republic a place where Jews were equal partakers in its benefits.

What did Rabbi Moshe Feinstein say about Thanksgiving?

Rabbi Feinstein did not consider Thanksgiving idolatry or a religious holiday. In his final responsum on it, from 1981, he wrote that it is preferable not to celebrate it but allowed observance as long as it is not treated as an obligation.

Is turkey kosher?

Yes. Turkey is a New World bird, so its kosher status rests on tradition, or mesorah, which OU Kosher affirms. A kosher Thanksgiving uses a kosher-certified turkey and keeps every side dish and dessert free of dairy.

What was Thanksgivukkah?

Thanksgivukkah was 2013, when the first Hanukkah candle was lit on Wednesday, November 27, making Thanksgiving the first full day of Hanukkah. JTA called it a calendar rarity. In 2070, the first candle falls on Thanksgiving evening.

← Back to all posts

You Might Also Like

history

The Complete History of Jews in America (1654 to Today)

history

The Stories Behind Jewish-American Patriotic Traditions

history

A Brief History of Jews in American Fashion